What’s More Important, Offer or Creative?

I read a lot of creative briefs. Some read like action movie scripts, some like comedies. Most bore me to tears.

Lately, many are focused on “savings,” especially promotional briefs. Clients are retreating from adding value and developing brand ideas at retail and moving to delivering more dollars off and larger discounts.

I can see why this is tempting. I can also see why consumers love it. But please, for the sake of your brand, don’t fall for it. Don’t discount the future value of your brand.

Brands today need to focus on the real value they provide by flexing their creative muscle and delivering messages with greater force. Get creative and find new ways to tell consumers why your brand is worth it in any market.

Hyundai and JetBlue have set the bar with their assurance programs providing consumer security in the case of job loss. JetBlue goes one step further and combines its offer with a powerful optimism campaign promoting core brand values and encouraging “private jet consumers” to trade down to JetBlue.

The GM Total Confidence Plan and the Ford Advantage Plans with Ford Payment Protection followed suit. But what do their “assurance” programs say about their products? If Ford or GM wants to win the quality fight for the “longest-lasting vehicles on the road” they should support it with the “longest-lasting guarantees” on the road. When you place your brand quality message side by side with your sales discount, you create real brand value, not just temporary offers.

To support this, a 2009 Yankelovich poll found that 70% of respondents said price cuts probably mean a brand was overpriced in the first place. And 62% said they assumed a discounted product was most likely old and the marketer was just trying to get rid of it.

What we’re telling our clients in today’s market is that even if they’re forced into a discounting scenario, the key to success is not in spotlighting the 20% savings. Rather, focus on the 80% incredible value you’re giving consumers, and the quality, consistency and history the brand represents.

If a client insists on slashing prices, remind them to consider the impact discounting will have on the future of their brand. The power sports industry is currently down 40% plus this year. Our client Kawasaki USA is offering deep discounts on their entire lineup. When we looked to structure a comprehensive sales event for them, we also developed a text-and-win component that requires consumers to visit dealerships. This gives dealers the foot traffic they need and provides Kawasaki with new leads, a re-contact strategy and a bridge to the future for brand sales.

The long-term strategy is quite simple: “You’ll love my brand for a lot more than just the price.”

Paul Kuzma ([email protected])is chief creative officer at Trisect, Chicago.

Got a topic you’d like to suggest for a “Thinking Out Loud” debate? E-mail [email protected] or [email protected]