too many companies are jumping into the Internet without considering some direct marketing basics. For one thing, they have thrown the customer overboard in their pursuit of the e-rush.
Lash yourselves to the mast and consider the following research findings:
– A 1999 study by Net Effect of best-in-class Web sites shows that 67% of online purchases are never completed due to inadequate real-time customer support.
– According to Datamonitor, 237 million online transactions were attempted in 1998, but only 22% were completed. Datamonitor estimates that $1.6 billion in sales could have been saved by implementing some form of customer service – a figure that escalates to $3.2 billion in lost sales for the 1999 Christmas season alone.
– Analysis by Forrester Research, as published in The Marketing Report, states that 76% of Web sites fail to meet basic requirements for a good customer experience. In addition, only 17% of sites had customer service woven in; keyword searches were precise and comprehensive on only 7% of sites; and 3.87% didn’t provide essential information at each user decision point.
– Per a Meta Group/MT study, “In spite of marketplace perceptions of the Web (e-channel) as a dominant customer contact point, traditional selling channels such as face-to-face selling, business partners, and telechannels continue to account for more than 95% of revenues.”
Or consider these little nuggets. The CEO of an international company decided that the Web presented such a strong economic benefit to the company that all other forms of ordering should be discontinued. What happened? Terrified managers conducted research and determined that only 10% to 15% of customers preferred the Web. And Julie Schoenfield, president of Net Effect Systems, says that “only 2% of those who visit a site actually make a purchase.”
Many corporations are lured to the Web because of the promise of substantial cost savings. The pulse of the bottom line throbs with notions of eliminating vast departments of sales people, order processors, etc. However, we need to keep our eye on the customer and realize that Web marketing does have a costthat hangs in the balance – the customer relationship.
The more effectively we can nurture that relationship, the more we can increase lifetime value. Rather than a complex formula, the best way to consider LTV is as the total business a customer may do with your company. As time goes on, your acquisition cost goes away, so every dollar transacted becomes more profitable.
Yes, we must be constantly vigilant about the quality of our goods and services. And yes, we must become zealots for our customers, rabid in our pursuit of customer satisfaction: communicating value to our customers (as our customers define value) through the media and sales channels that they choose.
Here are four tools for creating customer-focused (versus media-focused) strategies:
1. Voice of customer media and message preference research – Without being overly simplistic, the best way to identify what customers want is to ask them. The VOC process helps develop qualitative marketing data through one-to-one interviews with customers and prospects. The detailed, personal nature of the research yields results that are free from the pollution of group dynamics.
2. Reallocating budget to spend the most on your best customers – Marketing investments should be driven by potential return. Potential return is driven by the concept of “propensity to buy.”
Who has the highest propensity to buy? Likely the 20% of your customers who generate 80% of your revenue. But instead of allocating our marketing dollars to these folks, the prevailing wisdom says, “They already bought – we need new sales.” And so we concentrate on prospecting.
Important perspective comes from an AT&T study that (in 1918) concluded: It is five times more expensive to sell a prospect than to sell an existing customer.
3. The consensual database opt-in process – The true role of a database is to drive the allocation of resources. However, the database can only be as effective as the customer information it draws upon.
The consensual database opt-in process provides a quantum leap in the clarity and accountability of the customer information, because the information comes directly from customers – not third-party sources.
There has been a consistent theme rising from over 500 hours of VOC research: Customers and prospects find most marketing communications to be superficial and irrelevant – not providing them with the information they require to make an informed decision.
The answer to this marketing conundrum also came from VOC research – in the words of the CIO of a multinational corporation, “You think that because I’m the highest-level person in the department, you have to send all the materials to me. But that’s not how we make decisions here. I’m tired of being your executive mailperson, reading each correspondence and then forwarding it on to who really needs the information. I would rather sit down with you and tell you who needs what information, when they need it and via what medium. And I will refresh that information once a quarter.”
In subsequent interviews, nine out of 10 decision makers endorsed the concept and said that they would participate as the executive sponsor for their company.
How does this work in practice? IBM created a consensual database opt-in process and achieved the following results:
– 841% increase in qualified response.
– 82% conversion from responses to qualified leads.
– 80% increase in sales over the control group.
– 75% decrease in marketing waste.
– 6 point increase in customer satisfaction.
– 17% of the market in pre-sales activity versus 8% previously.
Want to hear it from the horse’s mouth? Here are the considered opinions of three “best-in-class” marketers, two business-to-business, one consumer. Each is an example of customer-centric, carefully integrated, multimedia, multichannel strategies to surround the customer with value-added communication options.
Andy Grim, VP of sales and marketing, Golden Rule Insurance
Golden Rule’s target market is small-business owners, self-employed individuals and others who not covered by group health insurance.
The prevalent idea is that the Web is only for transactions – and that the cost savings are very attractive. However, we found that our customers don’t buy health insurance that way.
A multimedia approach seems to work best for higher-ticket sales. Restated, the importance of the product to the client – i.e., commodity versus important/ complex – will determine whether a strategy that focuses on Web purchases or integrates the Internet into the media mix works best.
For us, it was the difference between being focused on the medium, or focused on the client.
We also found that Web advertising is ineffective. Advertising generates too many unqualified browsers.
What we found to be effective is investing our lead generation dollars in building mutually beneficial partnerships with other Web sites where we pay for qualified leads – not clicks.
Once we receive a lead, we then:
– Use e-mail to acknowledge the inquiry.
– Use direct mail to send them complete information, and an application.
– Follow that up with an outbound call from a licensed rep.
We have maintained our closing ratio of 25% to 30% while massively increasing our lead and sales volume by transitioning clients from impersonal generic Web sites to value-added, personalized e-mail and phone interactions.
The Web is a good lead generator for us – but not the only one. We allow clients to find us through multiple media: The client chooses. Once they declare their interest, increasingly personalized and timely follow-up is critical. Each customer “touch” must be value-added. Once we get to the outbound phone call, instead of saying, “Why are you calling me?” the client must say, “I’m glad you called.”
Nick Roelofs, director, electronic business initiatives, PE Biosystems:
The rate of change in life science combined with the vast amount of data available on the Web makes the Internet a mandatory tool for research.
This affords PE Biosystems the opportunity to competitively differentiate ourselves within the life science community. The problem is data overload. The Web will increase the amount of data – good and bad – that the customer can access. How does the customer find the specific piece of information in this infinite sea of data?
Our goal is to direct customers to the pieces of information we want them to see, and they feel they need. Through the integration of print, mail, phone, e-mail and personalized Web site access, it will be possible to engage in the value-added exchange of information and thus provide the exact information, in the right way, at the right time.
In the “new” world of electronic business, whoever has the right information/ message at the right time, wins. It is no longer just being “top of mind” – it is now “first to respond.” This requires integrated messages, timing and personal profile information.
Personalization of the customer experience is key not only to delivering the information they want in the form they prefer but providing a relationship experience that is meaningful to the customer. The more you know about your customers, the more tailored and unique their experience can be.
Remember, the customer is looking for a path out of information overload. The value of the site is personalized information. If it is done correctly, customers will increasingly “opt-in” with increasing levels of personal information to improve their experience.
Real-time customer service and support is mandatory. Even if you lose an order, if you are always there to respond with a quality answer, you will be given de facto “first right of refusal” in the world of information clutter. Real-time response will become the price of admission.
E-commerce, however, is new to many in life science. Although many scientists use the Internet at home for personal purchases, the adoption of e-commerce for laboratory purchases is just beginning. The main barrier is internal purchasing systems with approval processes that inhibit instant purchase via the Internet.
Some aspects of the sales process will always rely on the face-to-face-interaction of a field person – major product configuration/selection, prod uct customization and final relationship management. If the Internet can deal with the research aspect of the customer interaction, then the sales force can focus on the value-added aspects of the interaction.
Dennis Thomas, VP of sales and marketing for LaserTech:
LaserTech – a direct marketer of stamps, signs and other office products – is integrating personalized Web sites into its media mix. We have two competitive differentiators going for us:
1. We produce a superior product.
2. We will go the extra mile for our customers – and that also drives our media-mix strategies.
To prove our commitment, we are in the process of developing a specific Web site for each of our large customers. The Web site will feature all the products that are contractually approved by that individual company, so their employees can order easily as the need arises.
Now this sounds great when we’re presenting to the customer, but what if nobody comes to the Web site? Then nobody wins.
It will take the integration of traditional media – primarily direct mail, catalogs, inbound and outbound telemarketing – to stimulate demand from our customer’s employees.
First we plan to sit with each customer and create a consensual database. Together, we identify the end users and those who have purchasing authority. We record their reach information – phone, fax, e-mail – and their media preference for different types of messages, for example: catalogs versus product updates.
Outbound will be the workhorse. Our challenge will be to keep the contact value-added. Let’s say we mail a catalog. Outbound follows up the catalog with a two-fold message:
The first part will provide immediate value to the customer:
– By our records, you use the X and Y products.
– Here is what’s new, here are some tips on how to use the product better.
– Let’s both get on the Web and review some related products you can benefit from.
The second part will provide ongoing value to the customer, and to LaserTech: What has changed in the office? Who is new? How are our products working? What are new needs that we respond to?
Thus, the integration of media will be critical to satisfying our customers, and generating increased revenue.