Improved technology makes digital printing a viable way to get personal on a mass scale
WITH ANY NEW TECHNOLOGY, a lag is likely between what one hopes it will do and what it actually is capable of doing. So it has been with digital presses and their ability to smoothly deliver variable data marketing materials. After years of tweaking, upgrades and de-kinking, however, the general consensus is that the gap has closed, and while users describe the systems – and the results – as everything from “sophisticated” to simply “useable,” no one doubts that the current technology offers marketers an excellent chance of standing out.
“It’s no longer rocket science,” says Alex Hamilton, principal of Computer & Communications Consulting in Philadelphia. “These machines do what they’re supposed to do.” Unlike traditional presses, which excel at printing massive runs of static information and images, digital presses allow for changes in content and four-color pictorial elements from piece to piece without interrupting the process.
Doug Johnston, general manager and vice president of The Digital Printing Initiative (PODi), a West Henrietta, NY-based trade group, attributes the efficiency to “a convergence” of faster computers, better software and the recent introduction of Personal Pagination Markup Language (PPML), new standards that – like Postscript for printers – provide a common way to run variable data applications across different types of presses. “Anyone’s software can talk to anyone’s hardware,” says Dave deBronkart, PODi standards program director. “That will mean a lot more choices and a lot less expense.”
For marketers, the convergence means a true ability to customize printed materials well beyond the run-of-the-mill inkjetted names and addresses.
“You are only limited by your imagination,” says Patrick Fultz, vice president of marketing at Channell Communications, a Manhattan-based e-business solutions company. Creatively applied, he says, variable data printing (VDP) promises significantly better response rates, order size, and overall profit through cross-selling, upselling, fulfillment and acquisitions.
Fultz points to early adopter Whirlpool Corp. as a sterling example. When consumers call the appliance manufacturer’s 800 number, an operator asks a series of specific questions designed to elicit what’s most important when they purchase a major appliance in terms of color, price, style, size and other parameters. Would an creme-colored unit match their decor? Would an icemaker take precedence over the fridge’s size? Within 24 hours, the customer receives a relatively slim, high-quality, four-color printed brochure, including detailed information and photographs about products, including that creme-colored refrigerator with an icemaker, and a list of local retail outlets. As a result, says Fultz, Whirlpool has realized a shorter sales cycle and a 15% to 20% reduction in mailing traditional paper catalogs, as well as a better relationship with its customers. “You’re giving them exactly what they asked for. They don’t have to wade through a huge catalog of stuff they don’t want to find the stuff they do want.”
“The industry is moving from mass marketing to mass customization,” says Johnston, citing one of 44 case studies in PODi’s “Best Practices of Personalized Printing” report, being released incrementally on its Web site (www. podi.org). He points to an association of regional automotive dealers that has been using a VDP marketing program to drive sales.
For about two years, association members have been sending prospective buyers a tailored direct mail piece within 48 hours of their visit to the showroom floor. Information gathered by the sales rep is e-mailed to a data clearinghouse, and then transmitted to the printer. Each four-color, trifold piece includes a thank you note with the sales rep’s name, and pictures the exact model in the same color in which the customer showed interest, as well as the specific dealer’s logo and a personalized incentive, typically a sweepstakes coupon.
“These brochures are not just thank you notes. They are very relevant and timely. Car dealers don’t have the luxury of waiting, or of saying, `Oh, I guess they won’t buy it,'” says Johnston. According to a five-month study, the program yielded response rates of 10.2% to 13.4%. Of those, 7% to 9% of respondents purchased vehicles. Thus, 1,000 pieces produced an average of $27,000 in dealer profit margin.
Without question, the Web has helped drive the need and desire to customize print pieces. As Hamilton and others point out, the Internet is a model of one-to-one marketing and relationships that typically reach out to the individual. Amazon.com, for example, makes product recommendations to customers based on previous purchases. Nike.com recently began an online offering that allows customers to design their own sneakers. The online program’s savvy tagline: “It’s all about you.”
VDP, says Fultz, is “taking Web-customized information and pages and putting them in paper form. The Web has the raw power, the information. Digital printing is the high-quality delivery mechanism.”
The Internet has also proved to be an ideal “collection box” for data, says Hamilton. Agfa, a major supplier of electronic imaging equipment, has been successfully using the Internet as a gathering tool for nearly two years. Created and hosted by application service provider Banta Integrated Media, its “Agfa 1-to1” program asks users to answer 40-plus questions about their company. In return, customers get a 16-page customized workflow recommendation, including graphs, charts and product illustrations, which can be downloaded or digitally printed and snailmailed within two days. Vaughn Taylor, Web manager at the Wilmington, MA-based company, says that all of the 3,000 visitors, who invested between 20 and 30 minutes filling out the questionnaire, subsequently met with a local Agfa sales rep.
Banta also created an online literature fulfillment program for 3M Dental, a St. Paul, MN-based company that manufactures and distributes more than 1,300 products used by dentists and hygienists. The purpose of the site, says 3M marketing manager Keith Haig, is to help its 50 authorized resellers create customized marketing materials and to distribute information to them. Banta’s software lets 3M dealers output a customized four-color, two-sided sellsheet with variable content including SKUs, pricing, channel partner name and logo, and customer service information. “We have realized our goals,” says Haig, including a consistent branding message, and significant savings in turnaround time and material costs.
The use of VDP is still in its infancy, says Hamilton. At least part of the reason is cost. VDP costs roughly between $1.00 and $1.50 for two sides of an 8 1/2 x 11-inch sheet, says Fultz. “On the face of it, that seems prohibitive,” he says. But viewing what you will spend through a traditional printing lens is a mistake, he adds. “Cost per piece is the wrong measurement tool. Cost per order and return on investment are the important metrics. You have to think differently about the business model, just as people had to do at first with the Web.”
Fultz and Hamilton say marketers need to factor in that response rates will rise dramatically. “If you usually get a 2% to 5% response rate with a 1 million mass-produced mailing, a customized mailing of 100,000 can mean a rate of 25% to 40%,” says Fultz.
Agfa’s Taylor believes color quality is lacking – and while that may be prohibitive for catalogers who rely on accurate color – for the majority of direct mail employing VDP, “that’s not the point,” he says. “Most people receiving these pieces aren’t looking that closely at the print quality. They are looking for information that is relevant to them.”
There are several ways to implement variable data printing (VDP). The route you choose depends on your goals, your staff and, of course, your pocketbook.
PROCURE THE SOFTWARE. Products range from Personalizer X, a Quark-Xtension, to the costly but powerful Pageflex from Bitstream, which is licensed on a per use basis. Simple programs like Personalizer X turn Quark into a database program, allowing the user to change text and graphics on a per customer basis. Bitstream’s sophisticated features includes layout flexibility within a single template.
The software option appeals to companies that want total creative control of their design, as well as those who have security concerns about data or don’t want the expense or maintenance headaches of the press.
Other programs: Focus Gold from Visions’ Edge, Scitex’s Darwin, Variable Information Postscript Printware from Xerox, and DataMerge from Meadows Information Systems, a division of Banta.
BUY A SYSTEM. Companies including Xeikon, Indigo and Xerox manufacture proprietary hardware, software and digital presses that enable you to do everything in-house. This is an expensive and labor-intensive option, cautions Patrick Fultz, vice president of marketing at Channell Communications. It may be perfect for the large corporation producing ongoing marketing or fulfillment projects, but it’s not appropriate for businesses that don’t have a significant volume. Buying the front- and back-end can run anywhere from $250,000 to $600,000. Ask yourself how much you will use the press, and whether you can afford to hire and train the staff you’ll need to operate and maintain the system. And factor in the expense of constructing an air-conditioned, humidity-controlled space to house the equipment, as well as machinery and staff for back-end tasks such as cutting, folding and mailing.
PARTNER WITH PRINTER OR OTHER SERVICE PROVIDER. To stay competitive, printers have in recent years bought or created application service provider (ASP) divisions that offer a variety of technological and marketing solutions. Independent ASPs have been springing up to address the growing demand for one-stop-shopping in one-to-one marketing, such as Clickupdate in Morristown, NJ. When evaluating any VDP partner, says Fultz, find out if it has database marketing expertise. “Without data, it doesn’t matter how many beautiful pictures and names are in the piece.” Also, determine whether the company understands what one-to-one means. “Inkjetting a name and address is not personalization,” says Fultz. And find out how much experience the firm has had using VDP technology. “It’s a new process. Some printers may not be conversant.”